Heron Park Swings Removed Due to Safety Concern

Heron Park Swings Removed Due to Safety Concern
Posted on 06/26/2018
An image of the aging play structure at Heron ParkThe swings at Mill Creek’s Heron Park have been removed due to a safety concern.

Heron Park is a popular park with community members. Residents who were young children when the park was built are now eager for their children to enjoy the park as well.

Last February, crew members whom are Certified Playground Safety Inspectors completed an inspection of the Heron Park play structures. Their evaluation was based on safety guidelines outlined in the current U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission Public Playground Safety Handbook.

This handbook addresses public playground equipment for use by children 6 months through 12 years. Since its first edition in 1981, the handbook has been regularly updated to reflect innovations in technology, knowledge gained about playground-related injuries and mechanical mechanisms of injury. It is estimated that emergencies rooms across the country treat more than 200,000 injuries per year as a result of children using public playgrounds.

The February inspection of the Heron Park play structures revealed that multiple items were out of compliance, including:
• Bolts on swing set created an entanglement hazard
• A play structure is within use zone of swings
• Concrete walls are within the use zone of swings
• Rot and insect damage in five posts just above the footing
• Vandalized and shattered Plexiglas bubble

“Following our inspection, City Staff contacted the equipment manufacturer to identify possible solutions,” said Gina Hortillosa, director of Public Works and Development Services. “We were advised to immediately remove the playground equipment from further use until the safety concerns are satisfied.”

Swings and bolts were removed to eliminate entanglement hazards and conflict of concrete walls being in use zones of the swings. The broken Plexiglas bubble was removed. A plywood plank was installed in the bubble opening to ensure there was not a fall hazard, which Hortillosa noted is “a cost effective, yet not aesthetically pleasing solution.”

However, these measures didn’t fully address the safety issues. Hortillosa and her team conducted a follow-up site visit on June 15 and other issues were revealed.

“The swing frame top can be easily accessed from the adjacent play structure and inadvertently used as a nine-foot-high balance beam,” said Hortillosa. “During the June 15 site visit, a water cup was found on top of the swing set frame. Very clearly the ability to be on top of the beam is not an imaginary risk.”

Further, rotten wood and insect damage of the footings were identified, which are signs that the play structures are close to the end of their useful lives. The Park’s wooden play structures are approximately thirty years old. Hortillosa ordered the immediate removal of the swing set frame following the June 15 site visit.

Local users are upset at the removal of the swings, but Hortillosa notes that at this time there is not a practical solution to address the life and safety issues presented by inadequate use zones of the swings. A rough order of magnitude cost estimate for the replacement of the play structure ranges between $125,000 and $325,000. Factors such as play area design, surfacing, and equipment chosen greatly influence the cost.

“With the upcoming development of the City’s Capital Improvement Program, staff’s top park project recommendation is the replacement of the play structures of Heron Park,” she said.